Blog > Is Phoenix a Buyer’s Market Now? What the Index Really Says
Phoenix is a buyer’s market now: the Cromford Market Index read 63.5 on November 14, 2026, well below the 100 that marks a balanced market.
As of mid-November 2026, Greater Phoenix is a buyer’s market overall, but not everywhere, and it is not a crash. The Cromford Market Index has fallen 17 points in three months, many Valley cities now favor buyers, and a few, such as Scottsdale and Chandler, still leaned toward sellers in mid-October. Prices have barely moved.
- The Cromford Market Index measures the balance between buyers and sellers, not home prices. At 63.5 on November 14, 2026, it sits well into buyer’s territory.
- The shift is uneven. In mid-October, Buckeye and Queen Creek read in the 40s while Scottsdale read above 140.
- The metro median sale price was $448,000 in October 2026, down only 1.5% from a year earlier.
- Whether this is an opportunity or a warning depends mostly on how long you plan to own the home.
- Freddie Mac’s 30-year fixed average was 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026.
Why does this matter now?
The index has been sliding for months, but the drop this fall has been fast. AZ Big Media reported that the Cromford Market Index stood at 70.1 for October 2026, compared with 78.8 in October 2025 and 92.6 in October 2024. By November 14 it was 63.5, which Cromford’s own summary describes as “a buyer’s market, 17.0 lower than three months ago.” An independent count points the same way: Redfin estimated that in September 2026 Phoenix had 105.8% more sellers than buyers, one of the widest gaps among the 50 largest U.S. metros.
Mortgage rates are the other half of the story. Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed average at 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026, the fourth weekly decline in a row, but still well above the 6.24% of a year earlier. Rates that high keep many buyers on the sidelines.
What does the Cromford Market Index actually measure?
The Cromford Market Index is a single number that summarizes whether buyers or sellers have the upper hand right now. The Cromford Report, a Phoenix-based housing analytics service, defines it as a short-term reading derived from the trends in active, pending, and sold listings, compared with the previous four years. A value of 100 is balanced, values above 100 point to a seller’s market, and values below 100 point to a buyer’s market.
What the index does not measure is price. A reading of 63.5 tells you that supply is outrunning demand: in the two weeks before November 14, Cromford’s supply index rose to 112.7 while its demand index fell to 71.6. Sellers face more competition, and buyers have more room to negotiate. It does not tell you that home values have dropped, or that they are about to. I think of it as a weather report for negotiating, not a price tag.
Which Valley cities are buyer’s markets right now?
The Valley is not one market, and the city readings show it. As of October 15, 2026, the Queen Creek Tribune, citing the Cromford Report, listed Queen Creek at 45.8, Buckeye at 48.5, San Tan Valley at 51.5, and Maricopa at 41.7, all firmly buyer’s markets. In the same report, Gilbert sat near balance at 96.7, while Chandler at 117.6 and Scottsdale at 144.2 still favored sellers.
Those city numbers have kept moving since. Cromford analyst Tina Tamboer told a recent market presentation, as reported on November 9, 2026, that Tempe had moved from a seller’s market to a buyer’s market, and that Mesa and Gilbert remained closer to balance but were weakening. Cromford updates its ranking of the 18 largest Valley cities weekly for members, so ask for the latest reading on any city you are considering.
In the October readings, the outlying growth areas had shifted furthest toward buyers, while established, higher-priced areas such as Scottsdale had held up better. If you are watching the West Valley, you can search available homes in Buckeye. If you are weighing a higher-priced area, the Scottsdale housing market data shows why sellers there still have more leverage than most.
For the city of Phoenix itself, AZ Big Media reported that homes sold in October 2026 at a median of $470,000, averaging 68 days on market and about 98% of asking price. That is a slower market, not a distressed one. You can search available homes in Phoenix, including North Phoenix, to see what that looks like on the ground.
If it’s a buyer’s market, why haven’t prices fallen much?
Because the balance of power and the price of a home move at different speeds. The metro Phoenix median sale price was $448,000 in October 2026, down just 1.5% from a year earlier, even as the index fell deep into buyer’s territory. Most owners have equity and low-rate loans, so few are forced to sell, and many would rather wait than cut their price sharply. The weakness tends to show up first in longer days on market, price reductions, and seller-paid credits, and only slowly in the median.
The drop is not even, either. Tamboer noted that the condo median has fallen from about $345,000 to about $307,000, and that homes under $300,000 are down about 9.5%, while the single-family median has stayed around $478,000 to $480,000. I went through what it would actually take for prices to fall sharply in What Would It Take for Phoenix Home Prices to Really Fall?, so I won’t repeat it here.
Are rising foreclosures a warning sign?
Foreclosures are up from their recent lows, but they are still a small part of the Phoenix market. ATTOM’s August 2026 report counted 186 completed foreclosures in the Phoenix metro, one of the higher totals among large metros nationwide. For scale, 5,155 homes closed across metro Phoenix in October 2026 alone. In the November 9 report, Tamboer described the current Valley as a mild buyer’s market, not one dominated by foreclosures and distressed sales, and said she does not expect a repeat of the 2007–08 collapse.
You may have seen a specific Maricopa County foreclosure count circulating on social media this month. I couldn’t trace it to the county or another original source, so I’m not repeating it. If foreclosures became a much larger share of sales, that would change the picture. Right now, the data points to a slower, more negotiable market rather than a forced-selling one.
Is this a buying opportunity or a warning?
Honestly, it can be either, and the deciding factor is usually how long you will keep the home. One Valley commenter put it plainly on a local market post this month: it’s a buyer’s market “ONLY if as a buyer you’re able and willing to hold long term.” I think that is mostly right.
The case for opportunity is real. There is more to choose from, with 27,427 active listings in October 2026, up 6.8% from a year earlier. Sellers are negotiating: by August, 58% of Valley sales included seller-paid concessions, with a median of $10,050. And rates have eased for four straight weeks, even if they remain above 7%.
The case for caution is just as real. The index is still falling, which means conditions could keep getting softer for a while, and nobody can tell you where the bottom is. Prices in some segments are drifting lower, so a buyer who has to sell within a couple of years could get back less than they paid once buying and selling costs are counted. And at 7.11%, the monthly payment is the real hurdle for many households, regardless of the purchase price.
Here is how I would think about it. If you expect to stay five years or more, can comfortably afford the payment today, and find a home that fits your life, a buyer’s market gives you leverage you didn’t have in 2021 or 2022. If your job, family plans, or budget are uncertain, waiting or renting a little longer can be the smarter choice, and that is a perfectly reasonable decision. For one buyer this market is a reason to move forward; for another it is a reason to wait.
What does the shift mean if you are buying?
It means you can ask, thoughtfully. Price reductions, seller credits toward closing costs, and rate buydowns come up more often than they did, but no concession is guaranteed, and what makes sense depends on the home, how long it has been listed, and your loan. The November 9 report noted that about 22% of contracts accepted four to five weeks earlier had fallen through, a reminder that the inspection period matters and that a contract is not final until closing.
I covered how concessions work in Seller Concessions in Phoenix, and whether to buy now or wait in Is Now a Good Time to Buy a House in Phoenix?. For rate and loan questions, a lender can tell you your options and limits; I am a real estate agent, not a lender.
What does the shift mean if you are selling?
It means pricing to today’s market, not to the high-water mark of 2022 or to what a neighbor got last spring. In a buyer’s market, a home priced above its competition tends to sit and collect price cuts, and it can end up selling for less than it would have with an accurate price from the start. Preparing the home, pricing against current competition, and staying open to reasonable concessions give a seller the strongest position.
If your home has been listed for a while without offers, Why Isn’t My Phoenix Home Selling? walks through the usual reasons. And if you are wondering whether this is the start of a crash, Is the Phoenix Housing Market Crashing? looks at that question directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good Cromford Market Index number for buyers?
Any reading below 100 tilts toward buyers, and the Ahwatukee Foothills News has noted that readings below 90 generally favor buyers. The lower the number, the more listings there are relative to buyers signing contracts. Greater Phoenix read 63.5 on November 14, 2026. A low reading means more negotiating room, not a guaranteed discount on any particular home.
Do lower mortgage rates change a buyer’s market?
They can. Freddie Mac’s 30-year average eased to 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026. If rates fall enough to bring more buyers back, demand would rise and the index would tend to move back toward balance, which can mean more competition for the same homes. That is a reason to compare the numbers on homes you like, not a reason to rush.
Wondering whether this market is your window or a warning?
The numbers in this article describe the Valley. Your decision depends on one home, one payment, and one timeline. Traci Kozlowski had questions about selling property and wrote in a client review that I “typed out a full breakdown for me to see the comparisons in the neighborhood and what my properties might be worth.” That is the kind of honest comparison I would do for you, whichever side of the market you are on.
Last updated: November 15, 2026
Tim Tiller, MSW, is a REALTOR® and team leader with Southwest Horizon Real Estate Services at Keller Williams Arizona Realty, focused on North Phoenix, Phoenix relocation, and senior transitions. He helps buyers and sellers read the Phoenix market with clear, honest numbers so they can decide at their own pace. Read client reviews.
If you are trying to decide whether to buy now, wait, or sell, send me the home you are watching (or your own address) and your timeline. I’ll put together a personalized buy-or-sell timing analysis using current local numbers, including the version where waiting wins. Start your timing analysis here, whether you are buying, selling, or both.
Tim Tiller, MSW | REALTOR®
Southwest Horizon Real Estate Services
Keller Williams Arizona Realty
602-805-7787 · tim@swhres.com

